From Pine View Farm

The Peace Train 0

Francis J. Gavin, writing in the Minneapolis Star-Tribune, considers Americans self-image as a peace-loving people and finds it somewhere between wishful-thinking and delusion.

I don’t agree with everything he says, but I think the article is worth the few minutes it will take you to read it. Here’s a bit:

Americans regularly make three curious and contestable claims about peace. First, they often assume that they are a peace-loving people, that our republic has been a force to promote amity in the world. Second, they assume that peace is an unalloyed good, both a tool and product of progress, providing incontrovertible benefits; war and conflict, meanwhile, have brought nothing but misery and disaster. Third, they see peace and order as the natural state of the world, and view any force that disturbs this harmony as both anomalous and deviant, to be identified, isolated and eliminated.

It is easy to understand why Americans embrace these views. If the U.S. and its citizens and values are associated with peace and stability, then actions that might typically be understood through the narrow lens of self-interest can instead be translated into selfless policies that benefit mankind.

(snip)

Or so the story goes. But an honest portrayal of our own history, and that of world politics over the past few centuries, casts doubt on all three assumptions.

Share

Comments are closed.