From Pine View Farm

Sauce for the Goose 2

Only a year ago, US intelligence officials were holding China’s feet to the fire over matters of cyber-espionage. A year later, it seems that the tables have turned. But in order to glimpse the hypocrisy of the US intelligence community, we must start in late 2012, when the US House Intelligence Committee first condemned two Chinese telecommunications companies, Huawei and ZTE, for alleged ties to the Chinese government.

(snip)

Revelations of the closely knit relationship between private US technology corporations and the NSA’s data mining efforts have not only brought Washington into the spotlight, but have had the same effect on US tech companies operating abroad..

Read the rest, in which the author puts forth cogent arguments that the rationalization for the electronic surveillance vacuum cleaner is less than persuasive when considered critically.

Share

2 comments

  1. George Smith

    December 23, 2013 at 1:52 pm

    I’m gonna repeat myself on this one from a few months back because there’s really not much new to add:  The US acts as if it is the exceptional nation in cyberspace. It reserves the right to criticize and lecture others on what constitutes proper conduct but reserves the right to do what it pleases because of its allegedly exceptional nature.

    The US, you see, only wages cyberwar, or cyber-espionage, campaigns in defense of freedom and to keep Americans safe. No other nations do similar things. They only cyber-spy on us and probe the net infrastructure to cause damage and steal our wealth.

    The country has been in a terrible position to talk terms in cyberspace ever since it started up a hot clandestine war on the Iranian nuclear program and subsequent related malware spilled over into other nations.

    The Edward Snowden affair only underlines it.
    One could add a chapter or two on the growing together of the private sector and defense structure in the national security megaplex and the fact that it’s a gigantic engine, one with a major focus in finding and security evermore revenue in tax dollars. Mix in the total apathy of the public and a supine media for over ten years in the cause of the war-on-terror. The fact that random ‘friends’ are outraged and posting on FB about an agency they never thought about before is trivial, people complaining about another thing they were too busy or self-centered to pay any attention to before it really got out of hand. 
    I would make Edward Snowden man of the year. Whether you like what you know of him or not, he did something that made a difference. Domestically, I would be surprised if anything changes. However, when Brazil cancels an order for American-made fighter bombers for Saab Grippens and specifically says US cyberspying was the reason one begins to see how external change might be enforced and extract a cost.
    Snowden derailed the propaganda train on China and cyberwar, bringing it about.  The cyberwar cult was always one of avarice and bootlicking stenography in the mainstream and tech press. At the end of 2013 no one with sense could possibly believe its a central issue threatening the economic lives and future of the majority,  a sword of Damocles hanging by a thread which we must empower computer security warriors to do something about. 

     
  2. Frank

    December 23, 2013 at 2:23 pm

    That’s as apt a description of “American Exceptionalism” as I’ve seen.

     

    America excepts itself from standards, international law (such as it is), and its own Bill of Rights.