From Pine View Farm

Tumblr Is a Very Strange Internet Place 4

But the end is clearly nigh.

After all, the potential buyer is the company that spent millions to convince the public to use a brand name to mean “web search.”

And now the public does a brand name to mean “web search.”

“Google.”

Share

4 comments

  1. George Smith

    May 19, 2013 at 2:49 pm

    Karp has focused on building the company’s user base for its minimalist blogging platform while leaving for later the question of earning money, a pattern typical for young Internet companies, …
    I looked at the capability and minimalist doesn’t quite do it justice. It’s good for quickly posting pictures and swipping, or “reblogging” them from others, nothing else. It’s “discussions” consist of “notes” which are simply slug lines that appear after a post if someone else has “liked” or “reblogged” your post. If it’s social networking it’s in the most atomized sense, as plankton socially network among themselves. No one knows anyone else on Tumblr, period. They just either “follow,” “like” or “reblog.” It is an utterly silent, almost speechless environment of millions, all doing the same thing. In a way, it is a perfect milieu for our time, a venue where no one has to look anyone else in the eye or say a word to them, even, just hit a “like” or “reblog” button. Hundreds of thousands don’t even put titles on their blogs which one quickly sees by all the “untitled” slugs at the top of the so-called “blog,” the place where it usually says “put yer damn name here” in the default installation. Perhaps the genius of it is that its worthless owner — who was making 13 million a year on it and now will be wealthier than Lichtenstein — figured out there were hundreds of millions of people, most of them young, with almost no desire to talk to other human beings or interact in any other way than posting pictures through a single push-button app, and only those pictures also reblogged the most by everyone else as mute as them. Internet plankton, krill, vast schools of digital shrimp, it’s the only thing I can come up with to describe it. Since I’m a word and language person I find anything that’s totally wordless and devoid of language in the extreme completely inhuman. That someone recognized, or lucked into, a program that attracts millions of such people is proof of something, I’m not sure what, but not anything good. What’s most depressing about it is the suspicion that it’s the future, the final endpoint decades from now, where everything is just the pushing of an app button a smartphone and your entire existence is defined or eliminated by the count of rebloggings and followers..  
     

     
  2. Frank

    May 19, 2013 at 3:32 pm

    I think that’s a fairly good generalization.  Like all generalizations, though, there are the exceptions, such as PoliticalProf and Contradict Me, but PoliticalProf is considering another platform.  The fellow who runs ContradictMe, though, started with a photo site.

     

    (Afterthought: I would hesitate to characterize a generation based on the users of a particular internet mouth-shooting-off thingee.)

     

    I find the “walled garden” aspect of Tumblr quite offensive.  If I have to log in to comment on something, unless I know it’s a site that has suffered attacks, I simply will not comment, though I may point and laugh from a distance.  I make exceptions for a few sites, such as the Booman Tribune and Brendan Calling, because I know the proprietors from my Philly DL days and know they have good reasons wanting authentication.

     

    I am also leery of third-party “comment management” systems.  They smell too much like data-miners for me.

     
  3. George Smith

    May 19, 2013 at 3:59 pm

    I tried it out to try and get a feel for what it could do. It has a lot of drawbacks. First is the logrolling circle-jerk nature of social networking in which you -must- ‘follow’ other people to even hope to start a readership. With the naturally attendant phenomenon, like Twitter, where people ‘follow’ you and quickly ‘unfollow’ because they’re trying to massage numbers. What also happens then is the blog windowpane fills up with worthless junk, all picture spam, and the only way to get a handle is to unfollow or ‘ignore’ individuals. That’s like the Facebook “news feed.” Second, all the Tumblr software does is recommend other picture blogs, or individual pix. Life on-line, to me — anyway, is not just a daily swarm of most reblogged pictures and sucking up. There are entire demographics of people who are not well-suited to social networking, in fact, are ill-suited for it. I am one of them. I don’t make friends easily and am certainly not much into logrolling. And Tumblr, as a blogging platform or a website anchor just wasn’t my kind of thing. The interesting part of it is that so many others feel so strongly that it is a great thing. I suppose it is generational. I’m old.  

     
  4. Frank

    May 19, 2013 at 10:22 pm

    I would never consider trying it out.  It is in my “I don’t care” category.

     

    As regards “social networking,” I have concluded that it’s neither “social” nor “networking.”  It’s an attempt to lock persons in, not to let them free.

     

    I don’t think it’s generational.  I think it’s intellectual.  

     

    You’ve either got an intellect or you don’t.

     

    No matter.  Yahoo will find a way to render it irrelevant.  It’s what they do.